Up to 4.4 million citizens in the UK now live in 'news deserts,' communities with no dedicated local print, online, TV, or radio outlet, according to GOV UK. These vast information voids leave entire regions without critical local reporting, directly compromising civic engagement.
Local news is crucial for informed communities and democratic health, but its rapid disappearance creates significant information gaps. The rapid disappearance of local news creates a growing vulnerability for millions.
Without urgent intervention and renewed support, communities will increasingly operate without essential oversight, leading to diminished civic participation and heightened vulnerability to corruption.
The United States will have lost one-third of the newspapers it had in 2005 by the end of this year, according to ncdd. This decline parallels the UK experience, where at least 293 local newspapers had closed since 2005, representing about a third of the sector, GOV.UK reports. The parallel decline across two major Western democracies reveals a systemic crisis in local journalism, indicating common underlying economic pressures. The erosion of local media infrastructure directly correlates with reduced civic engagement and increased opportunities for unchecked local power.
The Spreading Silence of News Deserts
Up to 37 local authority districts in the UK have no dedicated print, online, TV, or radio outlet, creating 'news deserts' for up to 4.4 million citizens, according to GOV.UK. In the US, more than 200 counties have no local news outlets at all, while over 1,500 counties rely on only one local news source, according to ncdd. The landscape of news deserts reveals local scrutiny is not just diminished, but entirely absent in a growing number of places. The physical absence of reporting infrastructure means local government actions, community issues, and public funds operate largely unseen, leaving communities uninformed and vulnerable to mismanagement.
Public Trust Remains, But Access Fades
Despite the widespread creation of news deserts, public interest in local issues remains strong. A survey found 65% of adult Oregonians follow news about local politics and community issues at least somewhat closely, according to agorajournalism. Furthermore, 75% of adult Oregonians surveyed trust information from local news organizations, agorajournalism reports. The disparity between public interest and shrinking supply reveals a market failure: strong public demand for local news meets a critically shrinking supply of trusted information.
The Vanishing Watchdogs
The crisis in local journalism extends beyond mere publication closures to a systemic gutting of investigative capacity. The number of journalists employed by the three largest local news publishers in the UK fell from approximately 9,000 to 3,000 between 2007 and 2022, according to GOV.UK. Similarly, two-thirds of local reporters in the US have lost their jobs in the last two decades, according to ncdd. The simultaneous loss of two-thirds of local reporters in both the US and UK signifies a severe qualitative decline in reporting capacity, far beyond mere publication closures. The decimation of the journalistic workforce means fewer eyes on local government, fewer stories uncovering corruption, and a significant weakening of civic accountability.
A Future Without Local Eyes
The continuous shuttering of local news outlets ensures a future where communities are increasingly uninformed and vulnerable to unchecked power, eroding the foundations of local democracy. On average, two newspapers shut down every week in the United States, according to ncdd. This relentless attrition, coupled with the millions already living in established news deserts across the UK and US, compounds the vulnerability of communities to unchecked local corruption and mismanagement. The primary watchdog function has been systematically dismantled, leading to a continuous decline in civic health and accountability. For more, see our Local News Critical for Democracy..
Given the persistent closure rate of local news outlets and the existing information voids, many more communities will likely operate without essential local oversight by the end of 2026, further eroding civic accountability.
